Map Holy Redeemer Church 5th & South Streets, Eagle Harbor, MI 49950 Add To Trip EmailPhone: (906) 337-4579US Toll Free: (800) 338-7982 Description The oldest Catholic church in the U.P. Built in 1852, it is still in use today as a memorial to Frederic Baraga and his labors. Open year round, Monday through Friday 9am-5pm, with extended summer hours. Videos TripAdvisor® Traveler Reviews More To Explore Categories: Historic Sites Attractions City: Eagle Harbor Region: Western UP Although the MEDC uses reasonable efforts to maintain the accuracy of the website content, it is not represented to be error free. Read legal information.