Body
A Chicago-style neighborhood tavern serving steaks, fresh fish, pasta, chicken, ribs, burgers, children's menu and daily specials. There is an outdoor patio. Lunch and dinner service daily. Full bar with live entertainment on the weekends.
Kenneth M | September 2025
Best Food and Absolutely the Best Service--Thanks Tamara!
Probably the best casual dining in New Buffalo but the thing that separates Casey's from the rest is outstanding (really outstanding) service. Our server, Tamara not only made our meal a total joy...
oldpirate2016 | August 2025
Location. - Vibe - Parking
Great location, Fun vibe, free parking in the back! Enjoyed the Perch Po-boy, Patty-melt and Onion Rings. The chowder which needed a re-heat, was outstanding. Lunch was quiet but it appears like...
Sherpa553334 | August 2025
Find a REAL Host or Hostess...
Most redeemable part of our visit here was Ariana our server. She was exceptional! She literally is everything you'd want, friendly, knowledgable and kind. Food was okay, nothing bad just acceptable...
Louise K | July 2025
Don’t order the perch.
When our table was ready after a 30 minute wait, no one was there to take us to our table. I had to let a waitress know. We ordered the perch and it was not very good. It did not taste fresh and was...
Anthony-Mormino | May 2024
Good food and dog friendly
American food and dog friendly, we got there a half hour before the kitchen closed at 10 PM. Place was very busy and had live music. Apparently the bar was open till 1 AM. Everyone was very friendly...
TripAdvisor Traveller Rating
Read all TripAdvisor Reviews
| Season(s) of Operation |
|
|---|