Body
A Chicago-style neighborhood tavern serving steaks, fresh fish, pasta, chicken, ribs, burgers, children's menu and daily specials. There is an outdoor patio. Lunch and dinner service daily. Full bar with live entertainment on the weekends.
Saturday M | August 2026
Love Casey's!
My first time at Casey's, and I loved the laid-back atmosphere. We sat at the outdoor bar area where my dog was able to go. I love the dog friendly. Also, that burger was Delicious!! We all had a...
Sarah C | August 2026
Terrible
I can’t even explain how poor my perfect was. I mean idk the last time I experienced such poor survive
sunofabeachStl | July 2026
Not Great.
Really poor service. They were busy outside but had plenty of space inside. They sat us, noone came to wait on us for at least 15 minutes. They were out of chicken wings. Seems odd that a bar is...
Connie H | June 2026
Great place!
Great food, great place! Recommend.
Kenneth M | September 2025
Best Food and Absolutely the Best Service--Thanks Tamara!
Probably the best casual dining in New Buffalo but the thing that separates Casey's from the rest is outstanding (really outstanding) service. Our server, Tamara not only made our meal a total joy...
TripAdvisor Traveller Rating
Read all TripAdvisor Reviews
| Season(s) of Operation |
|
|---|
What's Nearby
Kid's Attractions
Outdoors
Tours
Paddle Sports
Third Coast Paddling - Galien River Kayak & Paddleboard Rentals