Body
Brewster's Italian Cafe offers authentic Italian food including wood-fired pizzas, pastas, sandwiches and deli delights. There is an outdoor patio for dining and a new conservatory bar with a wine cellar and fireplace. Lunch and dinner daily with breakfast on weekends. Dine in or take out. Reservations recommended.
Cynthia A | August 2026
Typical "American" Italian Food
Restaurant brought food into hotel so cannot address anything but quality of food. I would say it was average for Italian food, nothing special. It was a lot of pasta which was to be expected...
titcombfamily | June 2026
Fantastic menu and patio dining
Terrific atmosphere inside and out - a nice weather ask for patio dining as you call ahead and make your reservation. Fantastic brick oven Pizza as well as a full menu. Enjoy the special place.
joekerib | August 2026
Freaky fast!
We had an 8:30p reservation on a Friday night and went in hoping for a relaxed family meal. Our experience fell short. Our waitress was personable, took our drink order and mentioned bringing bread...
EnjoyMyReviews | June 2026
Best of New Buffalo
The top spot in New Buffalo. Consistently very good. Salads, salmon, Roma pasta dish are excellent. Nice wine list. Comfortable setting. Great outdoor patio. Highly recommend.
sunofabeachStl | June 2026
Really dissappointed.
They have great outdoor dining. Food is mediocre at best. The shrimp in the pasta was over cooked and rubbery. The sausage was overly salty. Service was absolutely horrible. One of our guests...
TripAdvisor Traveller Rating
Read all TripAdvisor Reviews
| Features |
|
|---|---|
| Season(s) of Operation |
|
What's Nearby
Kid's Attractions
Outdoors
Tours
Paddle Sports
Third Coast Paddling - Galien River Kayak & Paddleboard Rentals