Syl's Cafe
713 River St, Ontonagon, MI 49953
Body
Casual dining specializing in pasties. We have the finest pizza around, fresh bakery, hearty meals, and delicious desserts. We also feature a full and hearty breakfast menu, several specialty salads and an excellent selection of dinners. On occasion the Cowboy Grill Team graces our cafe with their charcoal grills and hardwood smokers to prepare BBQ baby back ribs, beef, walleye, and salmon. We also sell hand crafted soap by the Wardynski Goat Company made from their goat milk. It's the perfect soap for blemished, dry skin.
Robert S | August 2025
Best Pasty’s in town.
Very friendly greetings and quick to be seated.
I asked in town who had the best pasty’s and I was directed to Syl’s. They were correct. It was one of the best I ever had. I added the gravy bowl...
Christine W | May 2025
A must stop while exploring The Pocupine Mountains, Ontonagon, MI
Syl’s Café is exactly what you hope to find in a small-town Upper Peninsula diner—friendly faces, hearty portions, and that warm, old-school charm that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back into...
SteveSly | July 2025
Great Little Cafe
We were staying down the road at Silver City and decided to drive into Ontonagon for something to eat. I had heard this place had great pasties so decided to check it out. My pastie was huge and...
Erica F | June 2024
Nice Stop
While traveling in the area, we experienced car troubles. After getting that under control, I had to find a place to do some remote work before we continued on the road. We stopped here and had...
Spicer E | October 2024
Worth the effort to find this gem
Read about this place online, we would not have found it otherwise, it's one of those precious little hole-in-the-wall local cafes that we love. Our waitress was a peach! so friendly and helpful...
TripAdvisor Traveller Rating
Read all TripAdvisor Reviews
| Season(s) of Operation |
|
|---|